?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Nature, Nurture, or No Chance in Hell?

Sam Carter: You know, you blow up one sun and suddenly everyone expects you to walk on water. -- Stargate SG-1

Over the past few days I've been seeing discussion here and there about whether writers are born or made. Tess Gerritson has some interesting thoughts about this: I think the ability to tell a good story is fully formed by the time we’re age twelve, at the latest. I was already writing stories at age seven. Age seven, in fact, seems to be the same age that many novelists say they knew they were storytellers. (Maybe because by that time we know how to read and write, and can finally commit our own stories to paper.)

In 1967, Kurt Vonnegut wrote an article called "Teaching the Unteachable": You can't teach people to write well. Writing well is something God lets you do or declines to let you do. Most bright people know that, but writers' conferences continue to multiply in the good old American summertime. Sixty-eight of them are listed in last April's issue of The Writer. Next year there will be more. They are harmless. They are shmoos.

And in this interview with Stephen King, he says this: You've got to be hungry for it. My mother said that when she was pregnant with me she'd go out to the road and take the tar up, and chew the tar, because there was something in that tar, that, she, I, needed. It's like a craving. We like to think about how smart we are. But I think talent as a writer is hard-wired in, it's all there, at least the basic elements of it. You can't change it any more than you can choose whether to be right handed or left handed.

I don't know. Yes? Maybe? In my case, I'd probably say yes. I started telling stories as soon as I could string words together, and once I learned how to write, bam. Wasn't anything good, but the urge was there. And I was very, very, earnest.

On the other hand, there are many different kinds of writing, and not all of them involve telling stories. And there are many ways to tell stories that don't involve the written word. Passion is as passion does, and whatever works and makes you happy -- is all that really matters.

Comments

( 6 comments — Leave a comment )
svilleficrecs
Apr. 14th, 2007 02:10 am (UTC)
"Mr. Vonnegut is working on a new novel, "Slaughterhouse 5." A musical version of "Cat's Cradle," an earlier novel, will open on Broadway this year."

Something about that tickles me, that it was written at the same time S5 was written. :)
meardaba
Apr. 14th, 2007 10:48 am (UTC)
I think there's a certain amount of creativity beaten out of us as young children in the assembly-line education we get (and I'm being very North American here). I think the writer is a person whose creativity and imagination was too strong for the system to purge, and that's why they feel the need to write.

I also think that there's a certain kinds of creativity, one being the storytelling kind. If you look at some homeschooled kids (and I mean the ones that were actually homeschooled, not the ones that are left at home to watch TV all day), they are often incredibly open-minded and fee thinking kids. They have creativity, but they're not all writers. Some are artists, some are scientific geniuses, some are chess whizzes.

Soooo...I have to say it's both. I know, I know, straddling the fence much? But honestly, I think everyone has a strength, or a creative force, but those who overcome the education they've had are the ones who have a stronger need to be creative than those who don't.

And to keep this all straight (and not sound like some uppity pseudo-writer), I am one of the many who lack creativity. I have no burning need to do anything but read.
mdhenry
Apr. 14th, 2007 04:21 pm (UTC)
You've got to cross post this to fangs, fur, and fey. It's exactly the kind of topic that the group jumps on and comments to no end.
meardaba
Apr. 14th, 2007 06:03 pm (UTC)
Are you directing this to me or to webpetals?
mdhenry
Apr. 14th, 2007 06:11 pm (UTC)
Oops. You're right.
mdhenry
Apr. 14th, 2007 06:12 pm (UTC)
You've got to cross post this to fangs, fur, and fey. It's exactly the kind of topic that the group jumps on and comments to no end.

Mark
( 6 comments — Leave a comment )

Profile

princess/frog
webpetals
Novelist, lawyer, adventurer...
Visit my website!

Latest Month

January 2009
S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Hunter Kiss Series

Powered by LiveJournal.com